Carrying history forward

I first visited the site of a former concentration camp in November 2011, flying into Hamburg on the anniversary of Kristallnacht. Seventy-three years before, in 1938, a maelstrom of organized street violence directed against Jews across Germany and Austria led to the detention of tens of thousands, along with the destruction of hundreds of synagogues, thousands of businesses, and nearly a hundred deaths. At that point, I had been focusing on concentration camp history for three years. My thought was that by traveling on those dates, local commemorations for Kristallnacht in Germany might reveal how public memory had preserved or forgotten these events.

My first night in Germany was spent in Bergedorf, a suburb on the southeastern outskirts of the city. I woke up early the next morning, put my laptop into my backpack, and walked four miles to the former concentration camp at Neuengamme.

At that time, I was writing a book about the Russian novelist Vladimir Nabokov and how he had folded his personal losses and his century’s tragedies into his fiction in ways that readers had missed. The aim of the trip was to find out more about Nabokov’s younger brother Sergei, who had been arrested first as a homosexual and later as a subversive, and then sent to Neuengamme.

Walking from the hotel, I wanted to see the view that those prisoners had seen, marching from Bergedorf to the former camp site as they had in the first years of the camp’s existence. Approaching the gates from the same direction on the same road, passing some of the same low-roofed houses that remain today, I hoped to glean some insight into the tiniest part of what arrival there had been like.

Neuengamme was open from December 1938 to May 1945, and more than a hundred thousand prisoners had entered its gates in that period. A reverent hush looms over the site today, but wartime pictures reveal a dense landscape of barracks, SS quarters, and administrative buildings. Sitting in the far north of Germany, it was the last major camp liberated by the Allies. On average, prisoners at Neuengamme had a life expectancy of twelve weeks. Sergei Nabokov survived 10 months there, dying in January 1945.

It took fifteen minutes to walk from one end of Neuengamme to the other. The main Nazi camps, I soon discovered, tended to be vast enterprises, not so much large camps as miniature cities of horror nestled throughout Germany—and later, in occupied territory.

Internment, detention, Soviet labor camps, and Holocaust references played such a key role in Nabokov’s work that it led me to wonder how concentration camps had even begun. I found very little on the origins of concentration camps before the Holocaust and the Gulag. I found it hard to believe that there was no English-language book about how this inhumane concept had entered the world and persisted over time.

Sitting in the archives at Neuengamme concentration camp memorial in November 2011, looking at Sergei Nabokov’s name in the Totenbuch—the book of the dead—I began to think I might write that story.

Neuengamme death registry entry for Sergei Nabokov (“Nabokoff, Sergej”) and other detainees who died January 9-10, 1945. Courtesy of Neuengamme Concentration Camp Memorial, Ng 4.4.1

During my short time at Neuengamme before heading to Berlin and Prague for other interviews and research, the memorial’s head archivist, Dr. Reimer Möller, was generous with his time. I sat down with him at one point to talk about his work and what he thought it might accomplish. It surprised me when he said that he did not do his work with any confident expectation that it would keep the same horrors from happening again. Instead, he suggested, all it was possible to do was to give people information, so they would know what had taken place. Whether that information would be enough to stop the kind of dehumanizing terror that had occurred at Neuengamme, he could not be sure.

The trip was only a week in all—far too short to do everything I had hoped to accomplish. I found the depth of commitment to detailing the history of what Nazi Germany had done extraordinary—the Neuengamme site hosts some 100,000 visitors a year. Yet as I wandered the streets of Hamburg on the anniversary of Kristallnacht, I did not see a single public reminder of or reference to the anniversary of the 1938 violence. Even when history is meticulously preserved at specific memorial locations, it sometimes remains absent from the fabric of daily life.

I returned home thinking about what is held in archives and at historic sites, and how the larger story of the camps could be shared with people who might never set foot in such a place. I decided to trace the long arc of concentration camps as a way to carry history forward, though it would be up to readers to decide whether this knowledge might make a difference.

2 thoughts on “Carrying history forward

  1. Reblogged this on As the Adjunctiverse Turns and commented:
    History of predecessors to contemporary incarnations, however renamed as family detention centers or refugee camps

    “A haunting history of modernity’s greatest tragedy: concentration camps. Coming from Little, Brown in September 2017.

    Beginning with 1890s Cuba and ending with Guantanamo today, [Andrea Pitzer pinpoints camps around the world. From the Philippines and Southern Africa in the early twentieth century to the Soviet Gulag and detention camps in China and North Korea that took root during the Cold War, camp systems have been used as tools for civilian relocation, political repression, and extermination. Often justified as a measure to protect a nation, or even interned groups themselves, camps have instead served as brutal and dehumanizing sites that have claimed the lives of millions.”


  2. Roger Reis

    Thanks for your article. I enjoyed reading it. There are thousands of stories that need to be ‘researched’, and told. A survivor once explained the ‘magnitude’ of the Holocaust by stating: ” If all the victims of the holocaust passed by a large wooden house, scratched it with a nail, the house would no longer exist. It would be nothing more than a ‘pile of sawdust’.”

    In 1979, I spent 3 weeks visiting 12 major concentrations throughout Eastern and Western Europe. It was an ‘unbelieveable journey’. It still that haunts me to this today. With the help of a survivor from Auschwitz, I was able to produce two part ‘documentary’ ; Auschwitz: Never Again and “The Trail of Tears: The Holocaust.” These documentaries were later used to teach young people about the Holocaust. I belive I was the first history teacher in Minnesota to write up a curriculum on the Holocaust.

    I too share some of your concerns regarding the ‘direction’ in which our Country is headed. Remember the old saying, “We have met the enemy, and they are us.” Let us hope that history does not repeat itself like what happened in Nazi Germany. No ‘Seig Heils’ in America.
    It should be a warning that only one half of one percent were mainly reponsible for carrying out the Holocaust. What is really scary, is that the National Socialist Party started with only seven people in Germany.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s